My Musings on the America's Next Top Model winner - SPOILER

Posted about 1 month ago, 119 Views, 12 Comments

From the beginning of this season I was all about rooting for this season's winner. I was'nt sure she was going to make it to the end based on season's past, but.... Big time props to the first "plus-sized" model to win ANTM!!  I think she totally deserved it with her All-American, Girl Next Door looks.  Not to mention that she took incredible pictures & in my opinion, did the best on the Cover Girl commercial.   I'm sorry to disagree about one thing tho - I dont really think that she's all that "plus sized".  I simply saw a beautiful, healthy looking woman that I consider a great role model for younger girls.   Coming from a person who has struggled with various eating disorders since I was 16 - I wish I had had someone like Whitney to look up to when I was a teenager.  So congrat's to the ANTM judges for getting it totally right this season.  Go Whitney!

 

Mar142003_700_lg

i don't mean to put down any previous struggles of your own, but it's really mean to all of us to put the winner in your topic heading....

Mar142003_700_lg

sorry, browser closed before i could ask if perhaps you could edit the topic heading so as not to spoil the winner for the other tivo owners out there....

Mar72003_699_lg

I'm really sorry! Took her name off the blog post description. Lesson learned.

Mar72003_699_lg

I totally should've thought of my fellow TIVO and DVR users. I DVR ALOT, and I know how much it sucks when someone - accidently or not - spoils the end of a show you are really looking forward to watching and seeing the ending of for yourself. Again - I'm sorry and it won't happen again. Please forgive me loglady!
:-]

Mar142003_700_lg

awesome!!! thanks so much...i knew it would be hard to avoid, so no harm (to be honest the boston globe had already told me that fatima didn't win so i had a feeling....)

forgiveness is yours!

Mar72003_699_lg

Thank you!!!!

Mar142003_700_lg

so i've finally gotten around to watching this finale and i really have to say that i'm surprised.

everything that the judges were saying seemed to point to their selecting anya, not to mention that her photos were better in many of the shoots.

that said, i understand WHY tyrant chose whitney, but i disagree. in light of the new photos (perhaps current, perhaps pre-antm) of whitney that are on the interwebs it points to one of two things:

1. the rumors about whitney gaining weight to get on the show might be true, thereby making many of her background stories about how hard she had it growing up less than true.

2. since the show she's lost a bunch of weight, invalidating why she was chosen as the winner.

either option is no good and leaves a bad taste in my mouth...

Mar72003_699_lg

I agree - it DID seem that they were going to pick Anya over Whitney during the deliberation. Truthfully, I wouldve been happy if either one of them had one. (Just not Fatima - I really didnt like her at all.)
Wow - I hadnt heard any of this stuff about Whitney now! If it's all true, then that SUCKS & Anya SHOULDVE won! You never can tell with these "reality/game" shows anymore. There's always the potential for let-down when they're over and all the REAL reality of certian people and/or situatuins come out. I admit that I can TOTALLY get sucked into my favorite reality/game shows. I guess we all need to watch with a grain of salt & remember that it's all for entertainment in the end.
So unless it was a typo - I couldnt help noticing that you, loglady, spelled Tyra "tyrant". Can I assume that you dont like the woman?

Mar142003_700_lg

it's not that i don't like tyra...watching that finale though it became really apparent that there was no need for 4 judges, just what tyra thinks is important...of course it is her show and all....

i am very interested to see how things work out w/this whitney story....i had heard rumors prior to the show that she'd gained weight just to get on there (having tried out before and being cut for just being average pretty)...she certainly is more striking as a full figured model than her other itineration....we'll see what happens....

hope this link works, scroll down to see some skinny photos of whitney

http://community.livejournal.com/ohnotheydidnt/23449254.html#cutid1

Mar72003_699_lg

Thanks for the website info. Will try it & let you know.

The reason I asked about Tyra is because I used to really like her when I first started to watch Top Model. (I came in with season 3 at a good friends recommendaton. Have always been glad I did. I DO like the show.) However, the longer I watch, the more "fake" she seems to me. I dont know.... And is it me or does she LOVE to compare the contestents to herself in her heyday? In my opinion, that's just an excuse for her to show more old pic.'s of herself. What's your opinion on the whole "Tyra being fake" thing?

Mar142003_700_lg

i really think that the more she's tried to 'keep it real' the faker (is that a word in this context?) that she's become....i'm sure you know about the ANTM drinking game take a shot every time she says fierce...take a shot every time she shows the models how they could have done it better

"your eyes were good like this <squints> but they would have been better like this <squints a little more and randomly swings head around> see what i mean?"

those might be my favorite moments of her shows.....these past two seasons of ANTM have been a little lackluster to say the least and depending on what happens next cycle i may be done for good, tyra having been a victim of her own success w/me

Mar72003_699_lg

....I'm sorry, what?....I'm having a little trouble concentrating....I still seem to have a wicked hangover....

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


Episode Recaps

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Back to Reality

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Cirque du Mark

Poll: Cop shows (Part 2)

What was the best cop show on TV from 1998 to 2008?

From EW.com