I have the best, I must do the worst. It's only fair.
1. Kristy Lee Cook " Eight Days A Week", Top 12
No. No. No. No. No. No.
2. Ramiele Malubay " Alone", Top 10
Do not touch that song ever again Idol girls! you cannot beat Anne Wilson, and you cannot beat Carrie Underwood! You are not Carrie Underwood! Get over yourselves!
3. David Archuleta " With You", Top 3
This is possibly the worst thing he has ever done. Not boring, not sleep inducing. This was outright awful.
4. David Hernandez " I Saw Her Standing There", Top 12
I thought Beatle songs were industructable. They aren't.
5. Garret Haley " Breaking Up is Hard To Do", Top 24
Did you forget him? I didn't. He looked like Leif Garrett and sounded worse.
6. Jason Castro, " September Morn", Top 5
I'm still not sure who is at fault, Jason or Neil diamond ( Neil wrote this claptrap). Either way, it was not fun.
7. Carly Smithson " The Show Must Go On", Top 8
Carly has a great voice. She should never sing this song again. Ever. Angry doesn't begin to describe it.
8. Ramiele Malubay " Don't Leave Me This Way", Top 20
Covering the classic disco standard should have shown us her big voice. It didn't.
9. Amanda Overmeyer " Carry On My Wayward Son", Top 20
I really hate this song. Not her. But it wasn't pretty.
10. Kristy Lee Cook " Coat Of Many Colors", Top 9
Seriously, she's supposed to be all country and she couldn't make me believe a Dolly Parton song? Dude, you ain't good at all.
8
Comments
Rose Tyler 05/19/08
No Brooke? Bless your heart. I was preparing for her Andrew Lord Weber Week misstep to be on here. I still think she did the right thing by starting over.
cookiemonster 05/20/08
I lurv me some Brooke. Slamming Brooke is like beating a puppy.
Bitten 05/20/08
I like Brooke a whole lot better now that I corrupted her.
SoIntoItGirl 05/20/08
Your call was right on the money - the little enchilada singing "My Boo" just isn't right.
BTY can someone get him toothpicks to prop his eyes open - man that bugs me!
Add a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines