Here are my rankings after the top 12 girls performance from last night:
- 1) Ramiele - she's a little firecracker.....I liked her performance, it was effortless. I'm nervous that her "hair and make-up comment" won't go over well with the viewing public......and I didn't think the shoes were cute at all.
- 2) Asia'h - there is something about her voice that is unique and unusual - I like it. I would have preferred to hear Amanda sing Janis, but I guess she already did in an unaired performance during Hollywood week.
- 3) Syesha - I liked her.....she wasn't shouting nearly as much as she did during Hollywood week. Although, there would be something wrong with a world that saw an ANTM winner named Saleisha and an Idol winner named Syesha.
- 4) Kady - I realize the judges didn't like her, but I think her voice is amazing. Plus, she totally won me over with her Britney impression.
- 5) Alexandrea - feisty....love her personality. She owned the stage.....and I like that she was reading Ryan's teleprompter when he was reading off her numbers.
- 6) Carly - pains me to do it, but here she is. I do like her lower register, but her "powerful" notes sound like screaming. I'm glad she fessed up to her failed record deal, but she made it sound like her failure was a direct result of the company going under, rather than the fact that she was dropped for lackluster sales. The make-up artists helped her by advising her to stay away from the yellow eyeshadow.
- 7) Amanda - I like her personality, but I think her voice is limited. I didn't understand a word she said during her performance, but I guess she was intentionally scatting.
- 8) Alaina Whitaker - good voice, but not memorable.
- 9) Amy Davis - she has potential, but was ruined by a bad song choice.
- 10) Kristy Lee Cook - look what happens when she can't sing Amazing Grace. Her performance was annoying, and it looked like she had practiced in the mirror before she went on stage.
- 11) Joanne - you're plus size, we get it. Her voice is too pitchy for my taste.....and she demolished a good song. Dionne Warwick would not be proud. Joanne just escaped a #12 ranking, because I decided this morning that I couldn't stand....
- 12) Brooke White - weakest voice of the bunch. I still can't get over her hairy armpits that she displayed during Hollywood week, and she completely turned me off by her Farrah hair moves during her performance. See ya nanny chick.
-Kelly
P.S. I like that they eluded to the reason for the mysterious absence of tattoo arm and amazing grace chick during the men's performance. I am so observant....thanks to my DVR.






Comments
Capncrunch 02/21/08
Great list for the girls! Almost spot on, switch 4) Kady and 6) Carly and I'll be a happy camper!!
Amy 02/21/08
Why does Carly bother me. I don't know what it is. She has a good voice and everything but for some reason I find myself voting against her. I liked Ramiele, Alexandrea and Asia'h. Brooke White annoys me too. Somehow she looked older than everyone else last night. I just don't get her. And I don't really feel like Amanda sang at all. I mean I liked all the styling and everything but where were the great vocals. Lets hope they all get better next week.
Add a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines