Kady: Oh, that high note was terrible...actually, the whole thing is terrible. I'm just being honest
Amanda: Oh no, I'm singing the Faith Hill football version of this LOL 'Cause I've been waiting all day for Sunday Night! I have no idea if the performance was good or not, since I was singing the whole time. I'll agree with whatever Simon said.
Carly: Well, she easily has the best voice. I'm waiting for her to get to pick her song. I think it'll be really good. Now I just get annoyed when they mention them picking the wrong songs! I feel bad for everyone being against this girl...makes me want to root for her even more.
Kristy: I like this song. Ya, hurting my ears! I think we could easily cut this competition down to six right now.
Ramiele: When you don't have a big powerful voice, it's not a good idea to sing a song like this. But this isn't the 'I get to pick my song' stage, so whatever. I like this girl, though. I hope she goes far. WTF is Paula talking about?!
Brooke: I like Carrie Underwood's version of this. If there's a female version of Jason Castro in this competition, Brooke is the closest to it. She's very mellow when she sings. Not over the top; she just sings it. I really liked it. She's married? Who are these people that go to the rehearsals?! They said Brooke's was BY FAR the worst.
Syesha: I was interrupted during that performance, so I have no comments.
Comments
IdolMom 03/06/08
Did you mean Jason Castro?? That is exactly what I said when Brooke finished; she's just so laid back and sweet!
JeanainNashville 03/06/08
While I don't think any of the girls have a chance and I, personally, don't give two hoots about any of them I will state this. If I had to chose from any of the girls it would definitely be Brooke. She's the only one that I can remember what she sings, because her interpretations of those songs tend to leave an impression.
Carli 03/06/08
Yes, I did mean Jason Castro LOL Don't ask me why I typed in the name of an ex soap star.
Add a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines