double_agent  03/29/08

BEST HATCH/STATION (tie)
the swan (exercise bike)
the looking glass (2 hot chicks)

BEST USE OF A PROP
Eko's Jesus stick

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
Tom (Mr. Friendly)

BEST FIGHT
Jack vs. Ethan in the rain (Homecoming)

BEST DEATH
Charlie (drowned saving friends)

BEST QUOTE
Actually, my fav is "We're the good guys, Michael."

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
Walt

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
all the men looking as if they never shaved, even before they got to the island

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
Kate's horse (What Kate Did)

BEST KISS
Kate and Jack (What Kate Did)

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
to stop pressing the button

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
"Tokyo Rose"

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
The Bible

BEST FAKEOUT
Boone's vision of Shannon's death (Hearts and Minds)

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
The four-foot statue.

BEST REVEAL
???It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
Actually, Meet Kevin Johnson was the best

Liz  03/29/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
the hydra (fish biscuits)
(Only for the great quote: You taste like strawberries. You taste like fish biscuits)

BEST USE OF A PROP

Hurley's Dharma van


BEST OTHER (besides Ben)

Tom (Mr. Friendly)


BEST FIGHT

Kate vs. Juliet in the mud (Left Behind)

BEST DEATH

Charlie (drowned saving friends)

BEST QUOTE

"Where are we?..."

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS

Walt

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS

Ethan everywhere

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL

having spiders kill Nikki and Paulo (Expose)

BEST KISS

Charlie and Claire (Greatest Hits)


BEST PLANS BACKFIRED

the raft gets blown up

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME

Stay-Puft, Jumbotron, Pillsbury, etc..

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE


The Bible


BEST FAKEOUT

The opening of A Tale of Two Cities

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD

Does Walt really have powers?

BEST REVEAL

??????It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD

Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD

Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)


BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)

The Constant

The Counteragent  03/30/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
The Swan, not only for the exercise bike but also records, food, shower, and most importantly, Desmond.

BEST USE OF A PROP
Eko's Jesus stick. Aww yeah.

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
Richard, in spite of the perma-eyeliner look he's rocking.

BEST FIGHT
Jack vs. Ethan in the rain. Jack hitting people is fun.


BEST DEATH
Dude, you've got some Arst on you.

BEST QUOTE
"Where are we?..."

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
Polar bears. Stop trying to kill people, guys.

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
All the men looking as if they never shaved, even before they got to the island. Scruffiness is not ok.

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
Ben's bunny con, the creepy mofo.

BEST KISS
Charlie and Claire (Greatest Hits)--not necessarily the hottest, but the one I wanted the most.

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
To stop pressing the button. Yes, Locke, you were wrong. Tool.

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
"Freckles". Duh.

BEST LITERARY REFERENCE
Heart of Darkness. Locke is soooo Kurtz right now!

BEST FAKEOUT
The ending of Ji Yeon. Tear.

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
The four-foot statue. Really guys, I just wanna know WHY!

BEST REVEAL
???It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass). Oh. my. god.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday). Favorite of the freighter folk by far. God, that was a lotta F's.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore). Hands down. The rest can suck it, because there is no beating this chick. She rules.

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
The Constant. Because everything involving Desmond is flawless. Also, it just ruled anyway.

jkcampbell  03/30/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
* the Swan (Desmond)

BEST USE OF A PROP
* Eko's Jesus stick. I want one.

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
* Richard (the ageless)

BEST FIGHT
* Jack vs. Ethan in the rain (Homecoming)

BEST DEATH
* Charlie (drowned saving friends)

BEST QUOTE
* "Where are we?..."

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
* Walt

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
* Ethan everywhere

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
* the time-traveling mouse (The Constant)

BEST KISS
* Kate and Jack (What Kate Did)

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
* to stop pressing the button

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
* "Freckles" with ???Crouching Tiger and Hidden Dragon??? as a runner-up

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
* The Wonderful Wizard of Oz

BEST FAKEOUT
* Boone's vision of Shannon's death (Hearts and Minds)

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
* The four-foot statue.

BEST REVEAL
* ???Locke was in a wheelchair?!' (Walkabout) only because I called the flash-forward (Through the Looking Glass) in the first 30 seconds

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
* Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday) with Clancy Brown as a runner-up

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
* Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
* The Constant. One of the best episodes ever, brutha.

fernie  03/31/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
* the swan (exercise bike)
Because if you were stranded on a deserted (or so you thought) island, a fully-equipped apartment is what you would most want, & least expect, to find.

BEST USE OF A PROP
* Hurley's Dharma van
Because it seemed a fairly random excuse for a fun, happy episode but ended up being both the place where Ben turned to the Dark Side & a way for Hurley to show he could kick **** as well as anyone else on the Island.

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
* Richard (the ageless)
Because he's the most mysterious, & seems like he might have all the answers. Plus, I REALLY want to know WTF is up with him never aging.

BEST FIGHT
* Jack vs. Ethan in the rain (Homecoming)
Because it was the first Losties/Others smackdown, plus rain makes everything seem approx. 108x more dramatic.

BEST DEATH
* Charlie (drowned saving friends)
Because he willingly sacrificed himself to save his friends. Plus, his death was the only one that made me cry.

BEST QUOTE
* "Where are we?..."
Because it pretty much sums up the whole show.

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
* polar bears
Because while it was awesomely unexpected in the pilot, the CGI is just too fake-looking for repeated appearances.

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
* the numbers
Because, with the exception of Hurley, I'm pretty sure they are just random occurrences in the characters' lives. (& hey, stubble's sexy)

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
* Ben's bunny con (Every Man for Himself)
Because it solidified his villain cred: everyone knows that good guys might kill other people, but only bad guys kill animals.

BEST KISS
* Sawyer and Kate (Confidence Man)
Because it was so hot & steamy it fogged up the inside of my tv screen.

fernie  03/31/08

Part 2 (sorry it's so long, I wanted to explain my answers! Great idea for a post, BTW)

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
* to stop pressing the button
Because when Locke's wrong, boy, he's REALLY wrong.

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
* "Freckles"
Because it's an endearment rather than an insult -- & it's the only one that stuck. (But a write-in runner up vote to "The artist formerly known as Henry Gale.")

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
* The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
Because the show is all about the castaways working together to overcome their individual flaws & find Home, wherever it may be.

BEST FAKEOUT
Can I have a write-in vote for the opening of "Man of Science, Man of Faith"? Because I honestly thought I had my tv on the wrong channel, & fakeouts don't get any better than that.

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
* Will we learn anything about Libby ever?
Because I was so excited to see Cynthia Watros's name in the credits for "Meet Kevin Johnson", but then she was in the episode for all of 30 seconds.

BEST REVEAL
* ???It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass)
Because the one thing I never thought would happen in a series about people being stranded on an island was them actually getting off the island.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
* Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday)
Because while he might be the most endearingly absentminded professor ever, he still managed to share useful information with another character & explain to everyone what was going on. Plus, bonus points for the hilariously awful flashback wig.

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
* Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)
Because while she might have the Baddest Dad of all the characters, she doesn't give a damn about him: she loves Desmond, & that's all that matters. And if he acts strangely & then disappears of the face of the earth? Well, then she's bloody well going to hunt him down & get some answers.

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
* The Constant
Because it featured great writing, acting, character development, some mythology clues, & maybe even some answers. Because I've never seen anything like it on tv before. And because I love Desmond & Penny, & that final scene where they finally got to talk on the phone & say they loved other made me cry, damnit.

Amy  03/31/08

Best Hatch - the swan -DESMOND!!! (worst hatch - looking glass - how dare you kill Charlie)
Best use of Prop - Eko's Jesus stick
Best Other - Richard (how do I get those genes)
Best Fight - Jack vs. Ethan (rain is good)
Best Death - Charlie (although Claire doesn't seem to care as much as I do)
Best Quote - Where are we (still relevant!)
Most Annoying on island sightings - Polar Bears (and now they have migrated to the desert??)
Most Annoying off island sightings - numbers (because I think they have lost their relevance)
Best use of an Animal - time traveling mouse (leave it to a mouse to explain the impossible)
Best Kiss - (wishing for Pen and Des to be in this catagory) for now Claire and Charlie
Best Plan Backfire - opps guess they should have kept pressing the button, Locke mistake number 108
Best Sawyer nickname - love them all, will go with freckles
Best Literary Reference - will go with Oz, though I like to find out about them all
Best fakeout - Tale of two cities (only because it actually faked me out) loved Ji Yeon but guessed it
Will the answer that Award - what is up with Walt
Best Reveal - through the looking glass - never guessed it
Best Supporting flashback actor - Jeremey Davies by a mile and lots of years!
Best Supporting flashback actress - Sonya Walger (love Pen and Des)
Best Episode - The Constant -cried at the end, darn it. Answered many questions, ask many more. Best episode EVER. (I thought they should have used that one as the one before the break)

CptSassyPants  03/31/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
the hydra (fish biscuits) - You had me at fish biscuits

BEST USE OF A PROP
Hurley's Dharma van - knocked out some others with it and we got to meet Roger Workman aka Skeletor aka Ben's dead dad

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
Mikhail (Patchy) - No explanation needed

BEST FIGHT
Sayid vs. Mikhail in The Flame (Enter 77)

BEST DEATH
Arnst (exploded) - Hands down. "You have a little Arnst on you."

BEST QUOTE
"Where are we?..." - There's probably a lot of others, but this started it all

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
Walt - Lesson learned. Don't have growing kids on a show where only 100 days pass by the 4th season.

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
Ethan everywhere - What's up with that guy?

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
Ben's bunny con (Every Man for Himself)

BEST KISS
Kate and Jack (What Kate Did) - I'm a Jate fan or is it a Kack fan... haha probably Jate

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
to stop pressing the button

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
None of these - Sawyer once called Jack Dr. Giggles. Love it.

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
The Bible
Heart of Darkness
Lord of the Flies
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
- Not really sure on this one

BEST FAKEOUT
The opening of A Tale of Two Cities - Very cool way to begin a season

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
Will we learn anything about Libby ever? - Still wondering here

BEST REVEAL
???Locke was in a wheelchair?!' (Walkabout)
???It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass)
- TIE - Two great reasons why I love Lost

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
John Terry, All the Best Cowboys... (Christian Sheppard)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
The Constant

boslen13  03/31/08

Best Hatch/Station: the swan???s exercise bike

Best Use of a Prop: Hurley???s Dharma van (and accompanying beer/Ben???s dad)

Best Other: Richard the ageless (Who? How? Why?)

Best Fight: Jack vs. Ethan in the rain

Best Death: Charlie (I cried???)

Best Quote: ???Where are we?...??? (Seriously, where are they?!?)

Most Annoying On-Island Sightings: Walt

Most Annoying Off-Island Sightings: the numbers

Best Use of an Animal: Ben???s bunny con (so intense!)

Best Kiss: Kate and Jack

Best Plans Backfired: to stop pressing the button (even when Locke is right, he can???t help messing up!)

Best Sawyer Nickname: The vast and various collection of Hurley nicknames

Best Literary Reference: The Bible

Best Fakeout: Ending of Ji Yeon (totally, totally didn???t see it coming!)

The ???Will They Ever Answer That???? Award: Cindy and the kids

Best Reveal: It???s in the future!!! (It was shocking, and the twist the show needed)

Best Supporting Actor in a Flashback/Forward: John Terry as Christian Sheppard (you can just throw him in any episode and it will be awesome)

Best Supporting Actress in a Flashback/Forward: Julie Bowen as Sarah

Best Episode of Season 4, Part 1: The Constant

Moononastring  04/01/08

BEST HATCH/STATION - the swan (exercise bike)

BEST USE OF A PROP - Eko's Jesus stick

BEST OTHER - Richard (the ageless)

BEST FIGHT - Jack vs. Ethan in the rain

BEST DEATH - Charlie

BEST QUOTE - "Where are we?..."

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS - polar bears

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS - all the men looking as if they never shaved

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL - Ben's bunny con

BEST KISS - Kate and Jack (What Kate Did)
but i kinda of liked the Jack/Juliet one too

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED - killing Ana Lucia and Libby

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME - Stay-Puft, Jumbotron, Pillsbury, etc..

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE - Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

BEST FAKEOUT - The opening of A Tale of Two Cities

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD - Will we learn anything about Libby ever?

BEST REVEAL - ???It's in the future?!' (Through the Looking Glass)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD - John Terry

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD - Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)

BEST EPISODE of Season 4- The Constant

Team Jen  04/01/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
??? the swan (exercise bike)
The swan rocks!
BEST USE OF A PROP
??? Sayid's bamboo torture
Nothing ???beats??? Sayid. Heh.
BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
??? Richard (the ageless)
I love Tom, but Richard is so intriguing!
BEST FIGHT
??? Kate vs. Juliet in the mud (Left Behind)
Gotta go with the girlfight here. It was so old school.
BEST DEATH
??? Charlie (drowned saving friends)
BEST QUOTE
??? "Where are we?..."
Classic.
MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
??? Walt
I could do without him at this point.
MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
??? the numbers
It seemed like there was all this mythology surrounding the numbers, what a letdown.
BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
??? having spiders kill Nikki and Paulo (Expose)
Spiders 1, lame characters 0.
BEST KISS
??? Sawyer and Kate (Confidence Man)
Boone and Shannon was just gross. I prefer Skate.
BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
??? to stop pressing the button
BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
??? My favorite actually, is ???Gizmo??? for Ben
BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
??? Lord of the Flies
BEST FAKEOUT
??? The ending of Ji Yeon
There???s no way Jin is dead. I???m convinced he???s still on the island.
THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
??? Will we learn anything about Libby ever?
BEST REVEAL
??? ???Sayid works for Ben now?!' (The Economist)
Shocking and heartbreaking, all at the same time.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
??? Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday)
Faraday is a great character.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
??? Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)
Can???t wait to see more of the Penny story.
BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
??? The Constant
A toss up for me between the Constant and the Economist, but this one wins out. It was a perfect episode.

Team Jen  04/01/08

BEST HATCH/STATION
??? the swan (exercise bike)
The swan rocks!
BEST USE OF A PROP
??? Sayid's bamboo torture
Nothing ???beats??? Sayid. Heh.
BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
??? Richard (the ageless)
I love Tom, but Richard is so intriguing!
BEST FIGHT
??? Kate vs. Juliet in the mud (Left Behind)
Gotta go with the girlfight here. It was so old school.
BEST DEATH
??? Charlie (drowned saving friends)
BEST QUOTE
??? "Where are we?..."
Classic.
MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
??? Walt
I could do without him at this point.
MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
??? the numbers
It seemed like there was all this mythology surrounding the numbers, what a letdown.
BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
??? having spiders kill Nikki and Paulo (Expose)
Spiders 1, lame characters 0.
BEST KISS
??? Sawyer and Kate (Confidence Man)
Boone and Shannon was just gross. I prefer Skate.
BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
??? to stop pressing the button
BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
??? My favorite actually, is ???Gizmo??? for Ben
BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
??? Lord of the Flies
BEST FAKEOUT
??? The ending of Ji Yeon
There???s no way Jin is dead. I???m convinced he???s still on the island.
THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
??? Will we learn anything about Libby ever?
BEST REVEAL
??? ???Sayid works for Ben now?!' (The Economist)
Shocking and heartbreaking, all at the same time.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
??? Jeremy Davies, The Constant (Daniel Faraday)
Faraday is a great character.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
??? Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)
Can???t wait to see more of the Penny story.
BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
??? The Constant
A toss up for me between the Constant and the Economist, but this one wins out. It was a perfect episode.

Team Jen  04/01/08

ugh - sorry for the multiple posts! I'm not sure what happened.

Salemskeeper  04/02/08

I think the best death should be Nikki & Paulo(Expose). I think it was such a creative, innovative, different way to die! To be completely & totally paralyzed so you appear dead, and then get buried alive! I wonder how long the spiders' poison would've affected them. Nevertheless, they died from suffocation. What a way to go!

Capncrunch  04/08/08

Rob Grizzly you totally rock for putting time into this! I had a ball reliving the memories!!

BEST HATCH/STATION
the swan (exercise bike)

BEST USE OF A PROP
Hurley's Dharma van

BEST OTHER (besides Ben)
Tom (Mr. Friendly)

BEST FIGHT
Sayid vs. Mikhail in The Flame (Enter 77)

BEST DEATH
Arnst (exploded)

BEST QUOTE
"Don't tell me what I can't do"

MOST ANNOYING ON-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
wild boars

MOST ANNOYING OFF-ISLAND SIGHTINGS
all the men looking as if they never shaved, even before they got to the island

BEST USE OF AN ANIMAL
Kate's horse (What Kate Did)
Ben's bunny con (Every Man for Himself)
having spiders kill Nikki and Paulo (Expose)
the time-traveling mouse (The Constant)

BEST KISS
Sawyer and Kate (Confidence Man)

BEST PLANS BACKFIRED
to stop pressing the button

BEST SAWYER NICKNAME
Stay-Puft, Jumbotron, Pillsbury, etc..

BEST LITERARY REFRENCE
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

BEST FAKEOUT
The opening of A Tale of Two Cities

THE "WILL THEY EVER ANSWER THAT?" AWARD
The four-foot statue.

BEST REVEAL
???Libby's in the nut house, too?!' (Dave)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Kevin Tigh, The Man from Tallahassee (Anthony Cooper)

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A FLASHBACK/FORWARD
Sonya Walger, Flashes Before Your Eyes (Penelope Widmore)

BEST EPISODE (of Season 4 So far)
The Constant