We open where we left off. The Doctor is still smarting from Martha’s departure (and a quick visit from an earlier incarnation of himself that likes celery on his lapel), when he flips a switch and is jolted back from his thoughts by what seems to be the TARDIS crashing into something. Random bits of ice and debris fly everywhere, and we see the bow of a ship slicing its way into the TARDIS. Much like last Christmas, when Ten is surprised by Donna in her wedding gown, he is flabbergasted exclaiming, “What! What?” A life preserver rolls toward him, and upon examining it he is more than a bit surprised to see the ship’s name “Titanic” emblazoned on it.
This is the point the show ended last year after the Last of the Time Lords. The earlier incarnation of the Doctor mentioned above is a reference to Time Crash, penned by the brilliant Steven Moffat and featuring Peter Davison back as Five. If you have not seen it, go find it out there on the interweb. Presented as part of last year’s Children in Need charity telethon on the BBC, it is a perfect blend of humor, poignancy, and fanwanking that any longtime Whovian would love.
Back to the TARDIS, which is quickly repaired and vworps onto the aforementioned Titanic. The Doctor makes his way around the ballroom area of the ship, which is then revealed to not be THE Titanic, but A Titanic in space that looks like THE Titanic, orbiting Sol 3, or Earth. And it’s Christmas! I wish we could get the Christmas specials at Christmas here in the US. It really puts you in the right frame of mind for some of the Christmas Miracle sensibility of these episodes, rather than the cynical, just paid my taxes, it’s supposed to be spring but it snowed twice this week sort of attitude I have now.
New Theme! It’s a bit drummier and rockier than last year. It’s odd seeing Kylie Minogue’s name flying through the time vortex. First we meet the crew, with the old mysterious up to something nefarious Captain and the young and fresh from training Midshipman Frame. Apparently we are on a cruise ship of the Max Capricorn lines visiting Earth for a holiday jaunt. Fleeting shot of Kylie in her waitress uniform as well as a jerk businessman, before the Doctor (now wearing a period tuxedo) asks the software challenged Heavenly Host robot where they are from. The robot reveals it to be a planet called Sto.
Due to jerk businessman, the Doctor meets Kylie, or Astrid Peth as she is called here (Note: Russell T. Davies LOVES anagrams. Astrid=TARDIS?). Both are lonely travelers and kindred spirits, methinks! Other folks we meet are cowboy-costumed competition winners Morvin & Foon, Mr. Copper the tour guide who knows a lot less of Earth than he claims, and alien Bannakaffalatta. The Doctor sneaks Astrid onto the tour down to London which is now empty. Evidently, Londoners are tired of their Doctor related annual Christmas alien attacks and make off to the countryside leaving the Royals and a not so random newspaper seller behind.
It seems the Captain is causing some meteors to move toward the ship and there are also power fluctuations in the engines. The Doctor snoops around a bit and discovers that the shields are down, and confronts the Captain via intercom. The Captain is none too pleased with this interference and pulls a gun shooting our poor midshipman while the ship’s passengers panic when the Doctor reveals the danger that is afoot. In my favorite line of the episode, one of the Host robots informs jerk businessman, “Information: You are all going to die!” After last season’s Blink, this show is really trying to give me a complex about Angels, isn’t it!
Due to a payoff deal with the unknown true villain by the Captain, the asteroids hit the ship like an iceberg, chaos ensues and now we’ve really gotten underway with the Towering Inferno/Poseidon Adventure storyline.
We lose the Red Shirt crewman right away in an airlock mishap, and we are left with jerk businessman whose name is revealed to be Rickston Slade, Bannakaffalatta, Morvin & Foon, Astrid, Mr. Copper and the Doctor. He sees the TARDIS floating toward Earth out of reach, while learning from Frame that the ship and the Earth below are doomed, as per the rules of Christmastime. The Doctor declares himself to be in charge, a Time Lord, 903 years old, and the guy that’s going to save the day. That seems to be enough to convince the others to follow along on the quest to reach the Bridge. Allons-y!
Along the way, we find out that Foon is in a lot of debt but Morvin still loves her anyway, Bannakaffalatta is a secret cyborg (a persecuted group on Sto), jerk businessman is indeed still a jerk, and the Hosts are murdering the remaining passengers. “Information: Kill!” After a third fat joke in poor taste about Foon, the Doctor and Astrid get flirty before Mr. Copper rudely interrupts them with his tale of woe. David Tennant and Kylie do have excellent chemistry!
The Doctor opens a hatch and now we have our “cross a wide chasm on an impossibly narrow beam” obstacle. A railing collapses and we lose poor Morvin straight off! Poor Foon! Jerk businessman makes it across (boo!) as the rest make their way across the girder. With the Hosts in chase, the group scurries across, only to learn that Angels have wings and attack people with their halos. Bannakaffalatta’s cyborg-ness saves the day with an EMP, but it unfortunately shuts down his power. Bannakaffalatta happy, but Bannakaffalatta dies.
Oh no! The Hosts reboot, and the Doctor tries to override the system with a security code, guessing random numbers (42! Hee hee!), but “1” seems to do the trick. Kind of like the air shield combo on Planet Druidia. The Doctor only gets three questions, helping very little, and Foon selflessly sacrifices herself to save the rest from the Host, joining her husband over the deck below. The Doctor gets back to being in charge, and Astrid invites herself along with the Doctor on the TARDIS “when this is all over”. She is so totally doomed.
Eight minutes to save the ship, and the Doctor orders the group to continue on to the bridge. He is headed off to figure out what mystery lies below on Deck 31, but before he leaves, Astrid plants a good one on him. The kiss is framed with sparks flying, and actual real live electrical sparks, not just metaphorical ones. Yeah, she’s doomed.
The Doctor gets trapped by the Hosts again, and gets “taken to their leader” on Deck 31. Astrid saves jerk businessman (boo!) and Mr. Copper (yay!) and tries to convince Frame to transport her to the very same Deck 31. Once again, doomed. Meanwhile, the Doctor meets the real villain of the story: Max Capricorn! It appears that he is now cyborged below, with just his head remaining on a robot body. The Doctor makes a bad joke about trying to “get a’head’ in business,” as he deduces that the 176 year old Capricorn is running the company and this ship into the ground for an insurance scam.
Capricorn does not take it well that the Doctor is trying to foil his cunning plan, and shuts down the engines himself. The Doctor is at the mercy of the Hosts, when Astrid appears in some sort of forklift. While under attack from Host halos, she loses the brake line and plows Capricorn over the edge and down into the engine chasm below. The Doctor tries to save her, but unable to stop the forklift, Astrid herself falls into the fiery depths. No! Not Kylie!
The music swells, the shots go slow motion, and the Doctor is in mourning for Astrid. The ship, having lost its engines is falling to the Earth, putting us all in peril. The Doctor is sad and angry, which you can tell by him walking in slow motion with flames behind him (see Runaway Bride, Family of Blood). Now that Capricorn is dead, the Doctor can command the Hosts to lift him up to the Bridge. He meets up with Frame, Alonso Frame. The Doctor is pleased that he can now save the ship AND make a witty pun by saying “Allons-y Alonso!” This is exactly why I love the Doctor.
The Titanic is not just headed for Earth, but Buckingham Palace specifically. This does not bode well for the Queen who if you remember, has stayed behind in London to show her subjects that aliens won’t attack this year. Boy was she wrong! The Doctor saves the day just in the nick of time, getting heartfelt thanks from the Queen and the random newspaper selling man. Merry Christmas!
Suddenly, the Doctor remembers that Astrid was teleported, and Mr. Copper confirms that the teleporter has a backup. If only he can get to that backup and bring her back! The Doctor fiddles with the controls, and Astrid reappears, only slightly and glowy. She cannot be brought back completely. Resigned to this, the Doctor kisses her, and lets her go so she can travel the stars being amongst them. It’s all a bit overwrought, but totally in the best Doctor Who tradition. It is (was) Christmas after all.
Mr. Copper agrees to go back to Sto and to jail, while jerk businessman gets uncharacteristically grateful and thanks the Doctor. Then he goes back to being a jerk when he realizes he just made a ton of money off this whole mess. Frame salutes, and turns the ship back to Sto. The Doctor gives Mr. Copper a reprieve by dropping him off to Earth to live out his days. The Doctor and Copper teleport on a snowy field in England where thankfully the TARDIS parked itself after the asteroid crashed into the Titanic. Much like the snow of Doctor Who Christmases past, this isn’t real either, as it is actually ballast from the engines of the Titanic. Then, in his misunderstanding of Earth history, Mr. Copper wonders if Great Britain is next to Great France and Great Germany, but according to the Doctor “Only Britain is Great!” But he has 1 million pounds on a credit card, and will be comfortable on Earth for sure.
After losing Rose to the Cyber-reality, letting Martha get on with her life, and losing Astrid so soon, the Doctor is in no mood for companionship right now. As Mr. Copper promises not to forget her, Astrid floats through the sky in the stars, the Doctor enters the TARDIS, and vworps away. Thus ends another Doctor Who Christmas special. A fine adventure indeed.
Up next: Donna’s back!






Comments
Rose Tyler 04/19/08
Very nice recap. I'm impressed by your Doctor Who knowledge. I am not alone in my nerd knowledge! My husband pointed out that the Spaceship Titanic is direct reference to a Douglas Adams game and book. Very cool. Anyway, I liked that the Doctor wasted no time "hitting" on Astrid! Oh his lines about seeing "the universe" will never grow old. I mean they would work on me!
Collin Kelley 04/19/08
It's too bad they didn't tack on the Time Crash short from Children In Need, but you can't have everything.
It was a great episode, but I was amazed at the body count in this episode. Mr. Davies really must not be a fan of Christmas. lol Alien hordes must invade and lots of people must die, including ones we actually like.
I'd like to see Kylie return as Astrid. I thought she was fantastic in this episode, and since no one is ever really dead or trapped in an alternate universe, maybe she'll come back.
Goldenaz4 04/19/08
Well, I'm glad to be back in my comfy, cozy hole on Fridays with the Dr. and BSG, but I wasn't that impressed byt this epidsode - sorry, that makes me a Scrooge, I guess.
I agree with Collin K. on the body count - it was almost as bad as watching the real Titanic go down. Notice how NO women survived? And I yelled "There goes Shelley Winters, too" when Foon met her demise (Poseidon reference). Still, Tennant is in RAREform - you can just tell he is having a BALL playing Dr. Who - who wouldn't? What fun filming that show must be! But this episode was just kind of ridiculously cartoonish. I dunno, maybe The Host just creeped me out too much. Or I am not a big Kylie Minogue fan. Or I was really tired last night...
But, there's ALWAYS next week for me, unlike the poor doomed passengers of the Titanic!
Rose Tyler 04/19/08
Ahh just you wait till next week. It's got the whole Doctor package. You'll cheer right up.
Collin Kelley 04/19/08
I've already seen Fires of Pompeii and it is a brilliant episode of the Doctor. And just watched Planet of the Ood...also fantastic. Catherine Tate is excellent in both of these episodes. Rose's return is foreshadowed in both episodes. Can't wait!
Collin Kelley 04/19/08
I've seen Fires of Pompeii and just watched Planet of the Ood. Both are brilliant. Catherine Tate is excellent both of these. She's got a dramatic side I didn't know existed, esp. in the Ood episode. She really moved me. The build up for Rose's return is foreshadowed in both eps. I'm really excited!
Rose Tyler 04/20/08
I've seen Fires of Pompeii too. It was very intense. I love the way Donna reacts to things. She's strong and mouthy. I like it! Also it should be noted that packed for her trip. Finally! How many times did we see Martha in that same leather jacket? Anyway I'm hoping to watch Planet of the Ood tonight. I love when aliens of the past return. Let the countdown to Rose begin!
jkcampbell 04/20/08
Very funny recap! I thought Voyage of the Damned was okay, but not my favorite of the Christmas Specials. The Doctor as messiah was a bit heavy-handed.
Overall though, it was fun. Great to have new episodes again. Allons-y Alonso, indeed!
Rose Tyler 04/20/08
Oh Collin my friend Danny would like your thoughts on a line from episode three. "Your song will end.", says an Ood to the Doctor. If your answer is to spoiler like we can discuss it elsewhere. Danny thinks it referrs to Tennant's future. I posted something about that on the group message board thingy.
Collin Kelley 04/20/08
I think it has something to do with Rose's return and the Doctor's imminent regeneration. Personally, I think we'll see the Doctor's regeneration in 2009 when they do the three specials instead of a full series. Then when series 10 begins, it will be with the 11th Doctor. I read somewhere over the weekend that Peter Davison agreed to be the Fifth Doctor, but was advised to stay in the role for only three series, which is exactly what he did. Since Tennant is a fan of that Doctor, I have a feeling he'll want to go out on a high note after series four.
Rose Tyler 04/21/08
That's what we were thinking too. I'd read that about Tennant being a fan of Davison. I do believe that Davison's daughter makes a guest appereance this series. My mate Danny wants Tennant to last as long as Tom Baker but Baker was around for 7 years.
rmiriam12 04/21/08
Wow! Love the enthusiasm for S4 so far. Also thanks for the compliments on the recap. Working on Partners in Crime right now. :)
FYI - I'm up to date UK schedule too. Just want to maybe gently suggest that any episode discussion on stuff that hasn't aired yet in the US move to the board so that those who want to read recaps can stay spoiler free? I set up message threads for all aired eps so far. Thoughts?
Collin Kelley 04/21/08
I've just joined up and left a thought. :)
Rose Tyler 04/22/08
Brilliant idea!
fernie 04/23/08
Nice recap!
I think the Christmas Specials do work much better at Christmas -- I spent this past Christmas in Scotland, & was very excited to get to watch "Voyage of the Damned" the way it was meant to be seen: through a fog of turkey & trifle, & so full of Christmas spirit that you don't even mind the relatives interrupting every 5 minutes with the resume of all the many guest-starring British sitcom actors. Cartoony adventure, romance, & slightly lame puns are just the thing on Christmas night, maybe not so much on a Friday evening in April?
But overall, I'd rank this in the middle of the Christmas Specials -- "The Christmas Invasion" is the best by far of the three, I think.
isabelle 06/02/08
This was a great recap and I haven't even seen the episode yet! But now I'm really looking forward to it. I'm in Australia and Dr Who isn't airing until July but I just couldn't wait that long. Thanks for building up my excitement levels.
I never like the Christmas specials as much as regular series but more Dr Who the better. Am I right?
Add a comment
Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines