American Idol

What did you think about this episode? Excited? Disappointed? Tell us all about it!

For the most part, the guys were great, except for Little David. Ramiele and Kristy Lee need to GOOOOO! I don't care which one goes first.

Although I have been apprehensive about Brooke, I will admit that she has grown on me. But, with that said... I've seen Keith Urban sing "Jolene" with alot more conviction.

Michael and Carly.. extremely well done.

I pretty much agree with everything Michael is saying. I loved the part about the macrame dreadlocks. I really think the bottom three ought to be Ramiele, Kristy Lee and David A. Ramiele I just can't get a grip on her. While I think she does have talent, she can not be the AI winner this year. Kristy Lee is kind of like the pretty popular girl you knew in high school. The kind you just love to hate. Maybe just a little insincere sums it up. And David A. has a great singing voice and really can belt it out, but does need to grow up a little and do some "high school musical" at home before he ventures out. His songs just don't affect me coming from this "baby", of course I'm no where near 16 either. I think David C. and Michael are definitely front runners. I love Brooke and looked forward to hearing her do "Jolene", but she's a little too happy to actually "feel" that song. I could not identify with her being the "wronged" woman. And yes, Syesha is seemingly the Whitney Houston wannabe. I really can't get past Carly's tattoo, so in my face. She does have a great voice, but she needs some image help, maybe some long sleeves to cover it up. So sorry if David C. had to make a trip to the hospital last night. Hope he's not upset about having to change his hair....I like it much better.

I do feel sorry for Ramiele, but she will not suffer much from this. She will find her niche. A word about the choreography as well.....yes, David and Ramiele did bump and Jason looked like the Scarecrow from the Wizard of OZ. I still like Brooke even though "Jolene" could have been more heartfelt. My bets for winner are between David C and Michael.