American Idol

What did you think about this episode? Excited? Disappointed? Tell us all about it!

When are we going to be able to post Top 6: Live recaps?

This is the same America that votes for the wrong pres candidates. Carly and Syesha in the bottom two???? Syesha is probably in the bottom two overall, but last night she rocked. Carly has done some brillaint things and she was in fine form with 'Superstar'. Jason singing Memory??? Puh - leese! The first thing I thought when they announced Sir Andrew week was make a rule, no 'Cats' and especially - under NOOOOOOO circumstances - Memory. And of all people to pick it, Jason "I didn't know it was sung by a cat" dreadlocks. Brooke "I can't take the pressure" has been downright bad the last few weeks but forget last night. Obviously nice and lack of tats is more important to people than talent.

I am still steaming - this is the same America that votes wrong in politics. C'mon - Carly has had some brilliant moments (think Dolly Parton week) and no train wrecks. Syesha, ok, I could live with her being in the botton after her best week ever, because she's been basically beauty pageant mediocre up until then. But what and who saved Brooke and Jason "I didn't know the song was sung by a cat" dreads???? The judges don't get it right very often but they called it tonight when they said it was a popularity contest. Luckily, history shows that the gifted artists make a career no matter where they finish, and the winners tank if they are mediocre (Taylor who????)