TV Fan

Where fans run the show

Entertainment Weekly

TV Fan Member Login
Forgot your password?

Featured Shows

American Idol FOX

Episode Recap

Write Your Own

Houston, We Have a Problem

By Michael Slezak | The Top 8 Girls | 03/06/08 | Comments (1)
Avatar-yellow
If I could vote any two women off the American Idol stage on Thursday night, I'd choose Whitney Houston and Paula Abdul. Let's be real here. Whitney and Idol are not, like the key ingredients in a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, two great tastes that taste great together
Comments Add a comment
Avatar-yellow

Amanda Overmyer is the devil-she is not "different" or Rock n' Roll, she is a miserable phony! That is one of the things I hate about American Idol is it tries to perpetrate that some of these people have niches or "scenes" that they just do not have or actually fit into. She doesnt sing she growls, she doesnt seem pleased to be there, or grateful, she seems like she is entitled and it really turns me off. What I want to know how the DUI-getting nurse has such a hot fiance? All the girls are pretty awful and COMPLETELY devoid of ANY personality (and not a whole lots of talent). I wish we had more of the men stick around for the final 12.

Add a Comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.
More guidelines


Copyright © 2008 Time Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.