Oct52007_957_lg shaggydan wins! shaggydan beat Gretchen 4 to 3.

The New Eliminator on American Gladiators is Not Nearly as Cool as the Old Eliminator

Oct52007_957_lg
Record: 11 - 6 - 2
Winner! 4
VS
Avatar-80EW.com Editor
Record: 1 - 1 - 0
Loser 3
shaggydan said

I want more cargo net!

Gretchen said

False. The new Eliminator is unquestionably awesomer than the old ElimiLAMEr. The old version is playtime; I've seen more impressive tests of physical endurance on Jeopardy. The new version boasts a pool engulfed in flames (not only a physical challenge, but a confounding scientific anomaly), and the new Travelator moves at speeds twice as fast as the original Travelator. I also know for a fact that three Gladiators died during test runs of the new Eliminator. Gladiators, who have the strength of 10,000 warriors and who can kill with a sideways glance, were virtually eliminated trying to conquer the new Eliminator. Seriously, I could beat the old Eliminator with my hands bound behind my back, blindfolded, and drunk. I could probably beat the new Eliminator if NBC would return my messages.

shaggydan said

Clearly, you've never heard of a little thing called 'Old School.' Tell me that you didn't grow up wishing you could have rocked that zip line right before the final couple challenges. Also, I prefer the obstacles where the Gladiators were standing in your way to victory. The fire on the water thing, that's just fireworks.

Gretchen said

What I am about to tell you is classified information. Perhaps you've heard the legend of the gladiator RugBurn. At his last known weigh-in, Rugburn was 362 pounds of concrete muscle, yet he was still as stealth as a wild lemur. He had the ferocity of a cougar, the physical attractiveness of a grazing giraffe, and the cunning of an animal who best demonstrates cunning. I tell you this because RugBurn recently met his demise while tackling the new Eliminator zip line. He fell from the cable prematurely and now, 98.2% of his body is covered in rug burns. He can no longer compete and his skin is permanently pigmented. The worst that could happen to you on the old zipline was some vertigo and nausea. I have vertigo and nausea just THINKING about the new zipline.
As for "Gladiators standing in your way to victory," I've heard that in the 80's, contestants frequently bribed Gladiators to let them pass easily for a cut of the prize money. While I can't provide you a direct source, I remember seeing 1,000 dollars fall out of Zap's spandex during the Joust.

shaggydan said

I remember the 1,000 dollar incident well, but if you remember the post game interview, the money wasn't from a contestant, but a payment for Zap's "Performance Enhancement" supplements. That's right. The old Gladiators were juiced, half crazed and all sorts of aggressive. These modern gladiators, however, are aliens. They're not human, they're strange space creatures from a planet far, far away, stored in huge water tanks like they had on Empire Strikes Back.

They look intimidating, but they don't have that slightly insane killer instinct that was required of the early Gladiators.

So I ask you, would you be less afraid of going toe to toe with those earlier Gladiators, or trying to hold onto a giant cylinder rolling down an artificial hill, knowing that there was no consequence should you fall?

Gretchen said

In The Empire Strikes Back (arguably the best installment in the Star Wars trilogy, I dare you to throwdown otherwise) you'll recall the emotional scene in which Han Solo was submersed in carbonite. The process essentially froze his body, keeping him alive, but in an incapacitated state. I tell you this because a similar process was used on the American Gladiators of the original series, in order to preserve their bodies for their triumphant 2008**prime time return. Arguing that the old gladiators are better than the new gladiators is ludicrous, because they are one in the same. It'd be like comparing David Hasselhoff in Baywatch to David Hasselhoff in Baywatch: Hawaiian Wedding. In the time it took me to explain this to you, I could have done 300 pushups using only my left arm. Translation: Don't waste my time.

*The gladiators were originally set to return in 2019, as foretold by Gladiator Siren #1 (the only deaf gladiator). However, there is talk that the American Gladiators Consortium orchestrated the writer's strike, which is an issue I plan to address in my tell-all memoir: A Gladiator at Heart, available in bookstores as soon as I make photocopies and leave it there.

Mar102006_867_lgEW

Forfeit, Danny Boy, forfeit!

Oct52007_957_lg

Never! In the spirit of Gladiators, I feel the need to fight through this impressive Throwdown response!

Mar102006_867_lgEW

Most entertaining Throwdown yet!

Oct52007_957_lg

Happy to hear I've changed your mind, Jay!

Mar102006_867_lgEW

Actually, I voted for Gretchen.

Oct52007_957_lg

Blast!

Oct52007_957b_lg

dan has some good points. new american gladiators is awesome... but not as good as original. in the new eliminator, it seems there are no incentives to actually make it across the "hand-bike" (should that be hyphenated?) or the stupid "barrel roll" as there were in the old eliminator. in the new one, you might as well immediately just fall to the mats below and continue, with no penalty.

Oct52007_957_lg

Ha HA!

Mar102006_867_lgEW

A hard-fought battle worthy of its subject!

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


Episode Recaps

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Back to Reality

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Cirque du Mark

Poll: Cop shows (Part 2)

What was the best cop show on TV from 1998 to 2008?

From EW.com