Dec122003_741_lg Gob316 wins! Justin forfeited.

AMERICAN IDOL THROWDOWN: Gambling-Wise, if you were to give me David Archuleta or The Field (the other 15), I would take The Field.

Dec122003_741_lg
Record: 2 - 1 - 2
Winner! 1
VS
Mar282003_702_lg
Record: 2 - 5 - 1
Forfeited 0
Gob316 said

I'll wait to see if anyone will take "Lettuce Boy" before I make an argument. But if you're curious, I could easily see Smithson or Asia'h taking out Archuleta. Bring it on!

Justin said

If I were you, I wouldn't place my money on Little David Archuleta yet.

Past seasons have shown us that the odds-on favorite early in the season almost never win. Tamyra Grey from Season 1, LaToya London in Season 3, and Melinda Dolittle from last season are examples of this. When performers start out strong in the Semi-finals, it is hard for them to continue that momentum week after week after week. I think that is exactly what we'll see happen with David A. Plus, I'm not sure if the Powers That Be may want him to win this season, he does not seem that marketable in today's music environment, but hey, then again neither was Taylor Hicks.

As for who may win, I'm not entirely sure, the overall group is rather lackluster this year, but I am certain that someone will shine and overcome David A., the early favorite.

Mar142003_700_lg

Uhhhh....aren't you both arguing on the same side?

Making this not a debate?

Am I the crazy one here?

Mar282003_702_lg

My bad, I was going off no sleep when I read the argument and I completely misread it.

Anyways, doesn't matter, Gaspy Mc"I'm only Seventeen!" is going down regardless.

Oct52007_957d_lg

looks like a partisan debate.

*flips coin*

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


Episode Recaps

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Back to Reality

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Cirque du Mark

Poll: Cop shows (Part 2)

What was the best cop show on TV from 1998 to 2008?

From EW.com