Avatar-30 The Throwdown ended in a tie, 2 to 2

30 Rock kicks The Office's butt. PERIOD.

Apr152005_815_lg
Record: 0 - 0 - 1
Tie 2
VS
Mar102006_867_lgEW.com Editor
Jay
Record: 2 - 1 - 1
Tie 2
MsBrightGal#2 said

The Office would never survive w/out Steve Carrell. The boss man is basically the only funny part of the show. I find Dwight to be pretty hit or miss.

Jay said

More people watch The Office. Therefore The Office is much better.

MsBrightGal#2 said

I believe this throwdown will be short and sweet. Since everyone at EW.com is obviously all very bright and witty. No one could possibly argue against me. Oh, WAIT JUST ONE MINUTE! Our boss man did! Oh Boss Man, you kid!
This reminds me of the fact that no one watched Arrested Development. Wonder which show would win among viewers, AD or 30 Rock? Hmm, something to ponder...

Jay said

Ah, I took an impossible position to defend, but you've given me an opening with this Arrested Development business. Arrested Development is better than 30 Rock!

MsBrightGal#2 said

Ayck! This is the last argument I'm given so i better make it good.
Uhm..................

Jay said

30 Rock is definitely better. But not butt-kickingly so. Therefore, I must be declared the winner of this debate. (Free puppies to everyone who votes for me!)

Jun132003_714_lg

Please continue this throwdown, I'm so curious to see more!

Jan252008_975_lgEW

I like Rainn Wilson, but hate Dwight. Odd. Jay was obviously joking so I'm voting for Sam. There's no joking on TV Fan.

Apr152005_815_lg

I believe this throwdown will be short and sweet. Since everyone at EW.com is obviously all very bright and witty. No one could possibly argue against me. Oh, WAIT JUST A MINUTE! Our boss man did! Oh Boss Man, you kid!
This reminds me of the fact that no one watched Arrested Development. And we can ALL agree it was a very, very bad, poor, horrible, not funny show.

Mar102006_867_lgEW

Sam must be DQ'd for having made the mistake of writing her "arguement" in the comments area.

Apr152005_815_lg

Ah- that would be admitting a mistake! But I do not make mistakes! I was merely attempting to get my point across by posting it anywhere possible. MmmHmm, that's right.

Apr152005_815_lg

Ah- that would be admitting a mistake! But I do not make mistakes! I was merely attempting to get my point across by posting it anywhere possible. MmmHmm, that's right.

Sep292006_899_lgEW

Here's where I get all legal-like -- based on their most recent episodes, 30 Rock is clearly a better show than The Office. But does 30 Rock kick The Office's butt? I'd say 30 Rock kicks, like, The Big Bang Theory's butt, no problem, but probably only playfully slaps The Office around a bit. Sorry...didn't mean for that to be quite as sexual as it looks...

Mar312006_870_lgEW

The humor on '30 Rock' is broader, sillier, and mocks the medium itself. Gotta vote for Sam, er, MsBrightGal#2!

Jan252008_975_lgEW

Adam, there is also no sex on TV Fan.

Oct52007_957_lg

Wait; Jay, you're offering free puppies on this throwdown too?

Oct52007_957_lg

How many puppies do you have available to give away?

Mar102006_867_lgEW

Not enough, apparently. I'll have to switch to kittens.

Add a comment

Remember to keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed. More Guidelines


Episode Recaps

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Back to Reality

  • So You Think You Can Dance: Cirque du Mark

Poll: Cop shows (Part 2)

What was the best cop show on TV from 1998 to 2008?

From EW.com